BooksForKidsBlog

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Idaville Interlude: Encyclopedia Brown: Super Sleuth by Donald J. Sobol

In every city and town across the United States, crime was a serious problem. Except in Idaville. For more than a year, no one--grown-up or child--had gotten away with breaking the law there.

Chief of Police Brown was indeed both smart and brave. However, the real genius behind the town's perfect arrest record was his ten-year-old son, Encyclopedia Brown.

Encyclopedia solved the crime at the table. Usually he had to ask just one question.

With this familiar opening, author Donald J. Sobol launches the twenty-fourth in his long-running Encyclopedia Brown series, begun in 1963, with his just-published Encyclopedia Brown, Super Sleuth.

Following a formula which has pleased middle readers over the years, Sobol crafts ten short mysteries, with a variety of Idaville's quirky characters and the usual suspects--especially Bugs Meany, the evergreen bully and his henchmen, the Tigers. Clues are embedded in the story, as is Leroy (Encyclopedia) Brown's astute interrogations and studied reasoning. All that each "minute mystery" lacks is the solution. The reader is invited to posit his or her own solution using E.B.'s own clues, or failing that, to read the solution to the case in the final section of the book.

Some solutions are easy enough for most middle readers to come up with. For example, in the opening "Case of the Hollow Tree," following a tip off, Chief Brown and Encyclopedia join a nighttime state park stakeout to watch a hollow tree where the loot from a recent robbery is hidden. In the moonlight they spot a man, walking along a path and tapping each tree he passes with his cane. When accosted, the man denies any guilt, saying that he is just out for his evening constitutional. In this case, most readers will point out immediately that the man's tapping proves he is searching for the hollow tree where the stolen money is concealed.

Other cases require more close observation. In "The Case of the Disappearing $300," the solution of the case depends upon close attention to the testimony of a drugstore owner who has had an envelope with three $100 bills, intended as bonuses for his three employees, stolen during the busy lunch rush. The solution lies in the answers each employee gives when he or she responds to E. B.'s obvious question as to whether they took the envelope from under the counter. When George replies that he didn't touch "Mr. O'Hara's "Ben Franklins," Encyclopedia knows he need ask only one more question to uncover the thief."

Then he quietly asked Mr. O'Hara one question:

"Did you tell anyone what was in the bank envelope?"

"No, I didn't," said Mr. O'Hara. "I didn't want to get their hopes up. I can't afford to give them a bonus if the money isn't returned."

Careful readers will instantly see that George couldn't have known that three $100 portraits of Ben Franklin were in the missing envelope unless he had taken it and looked inside.

Likewise, in "The case of the Patriotic Volunteer," Encyclopedia quickly unmasks a con man who claims to be a conduit for donations to a Presidential fund when he brags that he has visited the president and his family at their home in the Capitol in Washington. Kids who don't know their District of Columbia lore can turn to the "Solutions" section to be reminded that Congress meets in the Capitol and the president lives in the White House.

There are plenty of preteen sleuths in print nowadays, thanks to the success of Leroy Brown and his encyclopedic knowledge, but these titles by Donald Sobol are almost the only ones which feature short, three- to five-page stories, suitable for a quick bedtime read or silent reading time at school, with the key to solving each case in a separate section inviting the reader to become E.B.'s partner in crime solving.

For an overview of last year's installment in the series, the first in twenty years, and some other Encyclopedia Brown fare, take a look at my 2008 post here.

Labels:

Tuesday, January 06, 2009

Elementary! The Sherlock Files: The 100-Year-Old Secret by Tracy Barrett


My dears, the paper read. My very, very dears. I speak for the whole Society for the Preservation of Famous Detectives (SPFD) when I say that we are thrilled beyond words to welcome you to England, the home of your ancestors.

Go to the Dancing Men (if you're hungry, they make an excellent ploughman's lunch) and ask for a saucer of milk for your snake.* Then all will be revealed.


"The ink's fading," Xander exclaimed. Zena read the last few words hurriedly.

Please do not delay. We long to make you welcome. Time, as your illustrious ancestor used to say, is of the essence.

Although Xena and Xander Holmes had no idea that they were descendants of the great detective, Sherlock Holmes, the members of the SPFD--Mary Watson and the other descendants of Dr. Watson and, in a sly bit of literary allusion, Leroy Brown (Encyclopedia Brown to the cognoscenti)--soon fill them in on the family connection. In fact, Leroy Brown entrusts them with Sherlock Holmes' casebook of unsolved investigations, and Xena and Xander are soon off on their first case--the whereabouts of a painting, Girl in a Purple Hat, lost for over 100 years.

Working from a noted copy of the artwork and the cryptic notes in Sherlock's casebook, the two Holmesians begin their investigation in the hamlet outside London where the reclusive artist Nigel Batheson lived and painted only the members of his own family. Xena and Xander soon hit a dead end with their investigations: the artist's home had long ago burned, his only living relative can add little to the case except snippets of family lore about Batheson's three sons and a certainty that the artist had no daughters or neighbor girls who might have posed for the portrait.

Then Xander has a serendipitous breakthrough when Xena accidentally drops her wallet photo of him, girlishly costumed as a sunflower in a preschool play. Xander and Xena realize that the model for the illusive portrait must have been Batheson's youngest son, Robert, wearing a curly wig and a bit of a sulky look as he posed as a girl for his father's painting. Xander realizes that Robert would have feared being teased about his portrayal as a curly-haired girl and deduces that he must have hidden the famous painting in his boarding school dormitory room. Soon the intrepid sleuths are off to try to steal into the old dorm at the Worthington School for Boys in hopes of finding the illustrious portrait concealed there for a hundred years.

Tracy Barrett's The 100-Year-Old Secret (The Sherlock Files) is a real page-turner of a mystery, rich in setting and detail, well-plotted and full of foreshadowing which enable the reader to use the clues to solve the case right along with young detectives Xena and Xander Holmes. This is a series which has great promise for future installments for the mystery fan.

*The saucer of milk for a snake appears as a prominent clue in Sherlock Holmes' case of "The Speckled Band."

Labels: