BooksForKidsBlog

Wednesday, June 03, 2009

Man and the Moon: Papa, Please Get the Moon for Me by Eric Carle

Eric Carle's beautiful Papa, Please Get the Moon for Me is usually viewed as a book about the lunar cycle, with its fantasy story of the dutiful dad who tries to give his little girl the full moon, only to be forced to wait until it shrinks to a manageable-enough size to retrieve.

But this story can just as easily be viewed as a story with a sentiment which makes it well suited for Father's Day as well.

Before Monica went to bed, she looked out of her window and saw the moon. The moon looked so near.

"I wish I could play with the moon," said Monica.

"Papa," said Monica, "please get the moon for me."

Papa got a very long ladder. He carried the very long ladder toward a very high mountain. Then Papa put the very long ladder on top of the very high mountain. Up and up he climbed.

Perhaps all proud papas have moments of wishing to give their daughters the moon, but this devoted dad actually fetches a fantastic ladder and mounts it to the very surface of the full moon, where he sees that the moon is much too massive to manage by himself. But the wise old moon counsels patience, promising to shrink until he is the proper size for a plaything.

And Monica is pleased with her little crescent moon and plays with it happily as it wanes until it suddenly vanishes from sight altogether. Saddened, little Monica watches the place in the sky where the moon once soared.

Then one night, Monica saw a thin sliver of the moon reappear.

Each night the moon grew... and grew... and grew.

A loving father who longs to give his daughter her heart's desire not only does so, but also gives her a gift which continues to delight forever. It's a beautiful thought, beautifully executed. Carle practically invented the modern book-as-toy, and this one, with its four-page gatefold which shows the dad carrying a ladder so long it continues off the left and right-hand pages, shows his skill in creative book design with vertical flaps which open upward and downward to reveal Papa's climb up to the moon and back down to Earth with his prize.

Aglow with Carle's distinctive technique and palette, it's a lovely book with a lovely message for fathers.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, May 28, 2014

Re-Hanging the Moon: Sidney and Stella and the Moon by Emma Yarlett

SIDNEY AND STELLA DID EVERYTHING TOGETHER.

BUT THERE WAS ONE THING THAT SIDNEY AND STELLA DID NOT DO TOGETHER.

SIDNEY AND STELLA DID NOT SHARE.

It's a common problem between brothers and sisters, and when someone won't share a toy or the TV, it's usually not a national emergency.

But this time--it  might be.

Sidney has taken possession of a ball that Stella fancies, and as he darts off, the ball slips from his fingers and bounces toward an open window.

In fact, it somehow bounces right out the window and drops toward the earth. Sidney and Stella peer out at it as it hits the ground, and with their mouths open in astonishment, they see it hit the sidewalk outside and take a bounce--a BIG bounce!

HIGH! HIGH! HIGH!

UNTIL IT WAS SO HIGH IT COULD TOUCH THE MOON.  SMASH!

It did more than touch the moon!  It broke it in pieces which fell toward the earth. Oops!

Sidney and Stella run downstairs and look out their door, which opens into a double gatefold of the out-of-doors scene.  The sky is empty of everyone's favorite satellite, and all the neighbors are looking up, trying to figure out where it went. Even some astronauts are wandering around, looking for the moon.

Sidney and Stella feel guilty. They must be in BIG TROUBLE, right? There's only one thing to do to mend the moonless situation: come up with a NEW MOON--fast!

Emma Yarlett manages to stay just a bit over the line between believable and far-fetched in her missing moon fantasy in her Sidney, Stella, and the Moon (Templar, 2013), primarily through her dreamlike illustrations done up in midnight shades of blue.  Her fanciful solution of a glowing wheel of cheese found in the fridge may be a bit hard to, um, swallow, but preschoolers are often fairy tale fans and will chuckle at how the two now co-operating siblings work well together to accomplish their mission to re-launch their somewhat cheesy satellite into its proper orbit.

Read this one along with with Eric Carle's similarly themed and popular Papa, Please Get the Moon for Me (The World of Eric Carle) for a pair of dark-of-the-moon, pie-in-the sky lunar tales (see review here).

Labels: , ,