BooksForKidsBlog

Friday, May 15, 2009

Foiled Again! The Curse of Addy McMahon by Katie Davis

Anybody can have a bad day, but Addy McMahon is convinced that her string of bad luck, beginning with her father's death when she was nine, has to be the result of the curse placed upon an unfortunate Irish ancestor who cut down a fairy tree.

For example, there's the small but embarrassing incident where her rival for her best friend's attention sees her mother buying her, as she puts it to the saleslady, "a training bra." Then her mom, only one year, eight months, and three weeks after Addy's beloved father's death, not only has a boyfriend, but invites him to move into their guest room while he looks for a new apartment. Despite the fact that Jonathan is a successful writer, Addy's dream career, she finds his constant advice totally annoying.

But then, there's the BIG thing. When Addy interviews her best friend and co-editor of their school paper, The Seeley Times, for one of her signature up-close-and-personal articles, Jackie confesses, off the record, that she's got a crush on Ezra and he may have one on her. A bit jealous of her friend's sudden interest in boy-girl stuff, Addy vents her annoyance by creating a satiric graphic story of her friend in l-u-u-ve, even kissing with Ez. But when she saves it on her computer and emails her interview column to the kids on the staff to edit, she inadvertently sends the wrong file, and soon the whole school is laughing at Jackie's crush and angry with Addy for embarrassing her best friend publicly. It doesn't help that Addy's rival Marsha Pittel ("that's Pit-TEL, like French") moves right in as Jackie's BFF and takes over Addy's job as co-editor of the Times.

Disgraced and shunned at school and uneasy around the ever-present Jonathan at home, Addy is sure that her life is cursed forever. Depressed, she swears off writing, feeling sure that it is part of her family blight, even destroying the writeup of her last interview with her father before his death. It's a painful time for Addy as she tries to live with the consequences of her actions and the loss of both her friend and her writing. Her only outlet is her private journal, done as a sort of graphic diary which she calls her autobiogra-strips.

There's no fairy magic which makes everything in Addy's life right again. Gradually, she realizes that there's no curse, either--just her own personal responsibility for what she does and says. Addy finds the will to apologize to Jackie over and over until their friendship is reborn, and she even finds a way to apologize to Marsha for coming up with the nickname "The Piddle" for her when she first entered their class.

Understanding comes harder with her mother's relationship with Jonathan, but when she angrily shouts that she just wants her father not to be dead, Jonathan confesses his own feelings when his young wife died, also of cancer, and the two begin a better relationship, "post-curse," based on their shared loss and their shared love for writing.

Katie Davis' The Curse of Addy McMahon, is an impressive first novel, with a sympathetic but realistic character, immature but gifted, dealing with all the messiness of middle school friendships and blended family relationships.

A trailer including some of Davis' graphic illustrations for the book can be seen here.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, June 11, 2009

Drawing On Her Strengths: Ellie McDoodle, New Kid in School by Ruth McNally Barshaw

THE END

Seriously. This is the end. I'm doing this new journal to keep track of my family's move to a new house (new city, new schools, new everything). There won't be much to keep track of, though, because this is the END of everything good.

Eleanor McDougal, a.k.a. Ellie McDoodle, graphic diarist extraordinaire, introduced in Ruth McNally Barshaw's Ellie McDoodle: Have Pen, Will Travel, is back in an even-better sequel, Ellie McDoodle: New Kid in School. In this one, Ellie's problem is worse than camping with worrisome relatives in the woods: she's moving away from her six best friends, her house with her own room with her own clouds painted by her own mother on her own wall, her school where she knows everyone, and even her nickname, McDoodle, for her constant cartoon commentaries on daily life.

In the new place, she has to share a room with her high-school senior sister and go to a school where nobody knows her name and nobody can get it right. (On the first day she's called Eleanor, Allie, Ella, Elmo, Ollie, Ellie McDoo-gal, and, worst of all, Smellie McDoo-doo.) The school already HAS a best artist--Rachel--so nobody, including the cranky art teacher, Ms. Trebuchet, cares about Ellie's comic drawings.

But Ellie's got spunk and resilience and a dab hand for a caricature on her side. She sets out to find something good in her neighborhood and finds a humongous library and great woods to explore. And at school she finds a way to put her art skills and Ms. Whittam's social studies unit on non-violent protest to good use--organizing some long-needed action against the slow lunch line that leaves her class three minutes to actually eat their lunch--if it is indeed edible! In the course of designing a logo for the movement (a circle with a capital Q (for queue) with a diagonal line) and stickers and T-shirts with the logo for her co-protesters, Ellie wins the hearts and minds of most of the class--and the majority of the school board members--and becomes a fifteen-minute media darling when the protest turns up on the evening news.

Ellie even gets her nickname back from her new classmates and writes a new END to her current graphic diary.

THINGS I'VE LEARNED:

1) When I'm most sad, I should watch, because things are bound to get better.

2) A brand-new situation is like a blank canvas: I can be a real artist and make it great.

3) It's okay if new people don't like me right away. They will eventually.

4) From now on, I'm going to find the "new kid" and be friendly.

I need a new sketchbook. This isn't the end... it's only the beginning.


Ellie McDoodle: New Kid in School is an empathetic, funny, and highly readable semi-graphic novel, a format which seems to be in style these days. In addition to the best-selling Diary of a Wimpy Kid: The Last Straw, recent books which make use of this format for middle school girls include Katie Davis' The Curse of Addy McMahon, reviewed recently here, Margie Palatini's Geek Chic: The Zoey Zone, reviewed here, , Marissa Moss' Amelia's Notebook series, two of which are reviewed here, Rachel Renee Russell's Dork Diaries: Tales from a Not-So-Fabulous Life, and the similar format adopted by Newbery author Jennifer Holm in her unique graphic collage-styled Middle School Is Worse Than Meatloaf: A Year Told Through Stuff, reviewed here. All of these engaging middle school characters are transitional sisters under the skin with whom 'tween readers will feel right at home.

Labels: , ,